High Turnover Rates in Insurance Industry: The Impact of Low Base Pay and Commission Structures

Allen Bauer
3 min readMar 23, 2023

Insurance companies and agencies are facing a tough challenge when it comes to keeping their agents and minimizing turnover rates. One of the reasons behind this problem is the decreasing base pay to low levels or straight commission. As a result, employees are more prone to work at a place that has a livable base wage with the opportunity to make commission and bonuses above and beyond.

When we talk about the insurance industry, we can clearly see that it is highly competitive, and the demand for experienced agents is always high. Insurance agents are the backbone of the insurance industry, and their primary responsibility is to sell insurance policies and generate revenue for the company. However, this job is not easy, and it requires a lot of hard work, persistence, and patience. Agents need to have exceptional communication skills, a good understanding of the products, and the ability to build long-lasting relationships with clients.

To be a successful insurance agent, an individual needs to have a strong financial foundation, which can only be achieved with a stable income. Unfortunately, many insurance companies are not providing a livable base wage to their agents, which is leading to high turnover rates. Insurance agents who are not able to make enough money to support themselves and their families are likely to look for other job opportunities. This is why many agents are leaving the insurance industry and finding jobs in other industries that offer a more stable income.

Another problem that is contributing to the high turnover rate in the insurance industry is the straight commission. While commissions can be a great incentive for agents, it can also be a significant source of stress and anxiety. Straight commission means that an agent’s income is solely dependent on their sales performance. This can create a lot of pressure for agents to make sales and meet their targets, which can negatively impact their mental health and well-being.

Furthermore, straight commission can also be a disadvantage for new agents who are just starting in the industry. They may not have the necessary skills or experience to generate a high volume of sales, which means they may not earn enough money to support themselves. This can be demotivating and cause them to leave the industry before they have had a chance to develop their skills.

Another issue that is contributing to the high turnover rate of agents in the insurance industry is the practice of cutting off renewals to agents entirely or only paying for a few years, but still expecting them to maintain that book of business without being paid on it. This practice can be detrimental to an agent’s financial stability and motivation.

Renewals are a critical component of an insurance agent’s income. When an agent sells a policy, they earn a commission on the initial sale, but they also earn a commission on renewals of that policy. This incentivizes agents to maintain their relationships with clients and ensure that their policies are renewed year after year.

However, some insurance companies have started to cut off renewals entirely or only pay for a few years, which means that agents are no longer earning commissions on those policies. This can be devastating for agents who have spent years building relationships with clients and developing a book of business.

Furthermore, even when agents are no longer receiving commission payments on renewals, they are still expected to maintain that book of business. This means that they need to continue to service those clients and ensure that their policies are renewed, but without any financial compensation for their efforts.

This practice is demotivating for agents and can lead to a decrease in productivity and an increase in turnover rates. Agents who are not being compensated for their efforts are likely to look for other job opportunities that provide a more stable income.

In conclusion, insurance companies and agencies need to re-evaluate their practices when it comes to renewals and ensure that their agents are being fairly compensated for their efforts. By offering a fair and stable income, commissions and bonuses above and beyond the base wage, and renewals that are fairly compensated, insurance companies can attract and retain experienced agents who can help them grow their business and increase their revenue.

#InsuranceIndustry #TurnoverRates #BasePay #CommissionStructures #Renewals #BookOfBusiness #FinancialStability #EmployeeRetention

--

--